Mamdani’s Election and its Impact on New York BigLaw

There is no question that the election of a Hamas and “globalize the intifada” supporting socialist with no relevant experience to Mayor of New York City will have significant consequences on the business and practice of New York’s major and elite law firms, the only uncertainty being how fast and deep the impact will be.  As a matter of demographics, a statistically relevant number of New York City residents who do not identify with socialism or the Muslim Brotherhood is contemplating the possibility of relocating to more embracing homes than New York City, or has already decided to leave.  See Almost a million people will flee New York City if Mamdani becomes mayor: poll.

For New York’s Jews the urgency is acute.  Even the 30 percent of Jews who voted for Mamdani will eventually be forced to accept the reality that New York is no longer a welcoming environment for us.  Mamdani’s election two weeks ago means that a majority of New York City voters either supports his virulent Israel-hatred brand of antisemitism, doesn’t care about his antisemitism or believes that free public transportation and cheaper rent trumps Jew-hatred.  His signaling last week that he views the work of Nefesh BeNefesh, a non-for-profit group dedicated to assisting Jews seeking to relocate to Israel, as a violation of international law, is only the beginning of the horror-show awaiting New York’s Jews under Mamdani’s imminent administration.  See Park East Synagogue Protest: What Does Mamdani’s Response Mean for Jewish New Yorkers?,  And see In Israel, Adams Raises Doubts About Safety of Jews in New York – The New York Times.  

The same strain of anti-Israel branded antisemitism that has infested our college campuses and cities and helped propel Mamdani to his current stature has also infiltrated many of our major law firms.  In an article entitled “Big Law’s Jewish Problem” published on October 20, 2022 – a year before Israel’s black Sabbath of October 7. 2023 – Kenneth Marcus, the Founder and Chairman of the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law, opined on the creep of antisemitism into BigLaw as follows: “The Jewish community has finally awakened to antisemitism on the college campus and in the streets — only to find it seeping into the corporate boardroom and, more recently, BigLaw…  Last week, White & Case LLP, a major international law firm, confirmed sponsoring a controversial conference on “Racism and the Crime of Apartheid in International Law,” featuring Omar Shakir. Shakir, a human rights activist, was once forced out of Israel by an expulsion order. The event was presented by the American Branch of the International Law Association, and was accused of promoting the anti-Israel Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement.  It was not a one-off. White & Case has also reportedly admitted — after initially denying — that it had sponsored a University of Chicago event earlier this month in which Shakir was invited to speak on Israel’s alleged “crime of apartheid.” BigLaw’s Jewish Problem | Algemeiner.com.  “Historically, White & Case faced criticism for defending foreign governments and the German railway against lawsuits filed by Holocaust survivors. Allegations have also recently resurfaced that this firm once relegated its few Jewish lawyers to back-office research work, and forbade them from interacting with clients…  [S]everal BigLaw firms [have] bankroll[ed] Berkeley Law’s anti-Zionist bylaws… The list includes some of the country’s leading law firms: Morrison & Foerster … as well as Latham & Watkins, Covington & Burling, Debevoise & Plimpton, Skadden Arps, Wachtell Lipton, and Weil Gotshal. These developments are concerning”  Id.

Since October 7, 2023, Jewish attorneys among the rest of the country’s Jewish population have only felt increasingly marginalized.  See The Rise of Antisemitism and Political Violence in the U.S. | TIME:  “Cases of antisemitism and hate crimes towards Jewish Americans have surged in recent years, particularly since the start of the Israel-Hamas war in October 2023. The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) reported that in the three months following the start of the war, antisemitic incidents in the U.S. skyrocketed by 361%.  And the impact continues to be felt.  According to the State of Antisemitism in America 2024 report, published in February 2025, 33% of American Jews said they have been the personal target of antisemitism, in-person or virtually, at least once over the past year. Meanwhile, 56% of American Jews said they altered their behavior out of fear of antisemitism in 2024. A notable increase from 46% in 2023 and 38% in 2022.”  Id.  

While Jews represent only 2.4 percent of the US population, Jewish attorneys in the US represent about 15% of the national lawyer population and by extension likely at least 15% of all partners at major law firms.  See What Percentage Of Lawyers Are Jewish? Find Out The Numbers – American Judicial System.  Jewish lawyers at major firms in Manhattan are increasingly dealing with hostile anti-Israel animus among their colleagues and considering heathier alternatives in New York and elsewhere including Israel.  See Despite war: American lawyers relocate to Israel: “Jeremy Lustman, partner and head of DLA Piper Israel group, considers this nothing short of a phenomenon. Recently, Lustman organized a specialized conference in New York that attracted 75 participants from Israel’s business leadership, bringing together prominent Israeli law firms and technology companies… He views this migration as injecting valuable human capital into Israel’s legal system, with these lawyers bringing international experience, business networks, and deep understanding of the American market.”  Id.  Lustman summarized: “Combined with increasing antisemitism abroad, I believe many Anglo-Saxon Jews in America are experiencing a moment of sobering reality. They’re questioning where they truly belong when confronted with campus antisemitism and hate crimes across the US and Europe. Jews in these regions don’t feel particularly secure right now – these aren’t especially safe places for Jewish communities.”  Id.

To their credit, some BigLaw firms like Sullivan & Cromwell have been particularly aggressive and unabashedly public in their efforts to root out Hamas supporters and apologists from their ranks.  See Thank You, Joseph Shenker and Sullivan & Cromwell – Hanover Legal.  Other BigLaw players including market observers however are clearly more sympathetic to Hamas.  See, e.g. Harvard Law Students Vote To Divest From Israel – Above the Law: “I do think they are correct to say that it is wrong to call for divestment and then single out Israel.. This is, after all, a concerted effort. For example, what about the American companies that are contributing to the [Israeli] war effort? Thankfully, the folks over at American Friends Service Committee have already done a bang-up job of compiling companies that are profiting from the genocide in Gaza…” Id.

As Kenneth Marcus noted:  “If [major law] firms “want to demonstrate that they are on the right side of these issues, they must stop underwriting antisemitism. At a minimum, they should freeze contributions to BDS, anti-Zionist, and antisemitic programming. That includes withholding contributions from any group that excludes Jewish speakers.  As employers, BigLaw should ask all law student applicants whether they have been part of any organization that excludes members, officers, or speakers based on their race, religion, or ethnicity. They should be explicit that this includes groups that have excluded Jewish speakers. Students who have been members of exclusionary groups should be asked what, if anything, they did to try to fix the problem.  Judges should do the same. Several judges have banned Yale Law students from clerkships based on lesser infractions than what we have seen at Berkeley. Judges should ask clerkship candidates whether they have been part of any exclusionary organization, including any group that bars Zionists. And if so, what actions did they take to try to eliminate the discrimination? At judicial nominations hearings, potential judges should be asked whether they will do this. If they decline, senators should weigh this declination in deciding whether to confirm…  They should ensure that their diversity, equity, and inclusion programs address Jewish identity and antisemitism. If they have employees resource groups for others, they should form them for Jews. If they observe ethnic heritage months, they should observe Jewish American Heritage Month as well.”  See BigLaw’s Jewish Problem | Algemeiner.com.

As the line separating racial and political diversity from a BigLaw work environment hostile to New York’s Jews is contemplated and continually redrawn, the question that remains is how many BigLaw players will leave New York over the next few years for more hospitable venues and the extent to which Mamdani and his administration will accelerate that exodus to the detriment of NY BigLaw.  As for Hanover Legal, we intend to continue to service the New York and increasingly Israel BigLaw markets for years to come.  

More Posts

Thank You, Joseph Shenker and Sullivan & Cromwell

There are many reasons why Sullivan & Cromwell is arguably the world’s most prestigious law firm, but perhaps first and foremost is the fact that they always seem to lead the market in doing the right thing when it comes to their clients, vendors and employees.   The firm hires the most talented and ethical people to service their clients, pays over-the-market rates to their valued vendors, makes doing business with them a pleasure, and compensates their own people at the very top of the market as well.